Valento’s Pizza & Hoagies

Reviews

• K A.

  star star star star star 3 June 2026

  Family owned and run by a former manager of larger pizza place on Pine Ridge that has been long since closed.  Delicious, unchanged menu from previous years; same food preppers from years past so there's consistency.  
  
  "Slice and drink" specials, fabulous subs, esp. steak cheese.  Thin, crispy crust, serve yourself beverages. Not fancy, but good, if not one of the top 2 best pizzas in Naples, FL.  
  
  I have been in during season and off-season multiple times and have overheard conversation by different people who have driven across the alley or down from Port Charlotte for a Valento's pizza dinner.  
  
  I have visited during lunchtime on Tues for my fav specialty slice (buffalo chicken) and drink, and have gotten back to my desk at Pine Ridge and Goodlette within an hour.  I have had dinner in the evenings and weekends -- All visits have been consistently good, orders correct, and the staff friendly and conscientious.  
  
  I did order a steak and cheese sub to go and was pleasantly surprised that I got it all the way to Vanderbilt Beach Road without it getting cold and soggy -- it was still piping hot!

• Chad S.

  star star star star star_border 1 June 2026

  Though I've been here multiple times over the last several months and they have screwed up my order on every visit, the food is always still awesome and they always try to compensate us for their mistakes.
  
  The perfect cracker-crust pizza with flavorful sauce (no idea how they get so much sauce on this pizza and still manage to prevent the crust from getting soggy).
  
  Their subs are always amazing.  We religiously get the cheesesteak hoagie and Italian and they never let us down (so long as they are made as requested that is).
  
  I keep wanting to give you guys 5 stars... just need to get the kitchen staff to pay more attention to the tickets so they get the orders right.

• Angela T.

  star star star star star 31 May 2026

  Delicious Pizza! If you like a thin and crispy crust fluffy and flaky on the edges! Top quality ingredients,and plenty of them! You will not be disappointed, especially if you love cheese! The sauce is a house-made marinara and is to die for! So so good! That's all I can say is  Yum! Visiting from California, wish this was in my hometown!

• Jerico S.

  star star star star star_border 27 May 2026

  I really like this pizza. It's actually in my top five pizzerias in Naples. When I'm craving something  different from New York style I go here. The recipe is based out of Minnesota.
  News flash New Yorkers, yes other parts of the country make pizza and no it's nothing like New York style pizza.
  
  " Well I didn't travel 1100 miles to try something different ! Can yous believe they don't have pond hockey here in Naples." He he
  
  The pizza is really good though. Cracker thin crust and the sauce is amazing. And don't get it delivered. Delivery is always the kiss of death. Just go in and eat it fresh.

• Mark B.

  star star star star star 15 May 2026

  Great local joint.  With wife & 16 yo son.  Extra Large 18" 2 topping + coke + H2O + bonus free beer with Yelp check-in. = $26.48 + tip. Happy Day!